An individual who successfully claims in the Employment Tribunal that they have been unfairly dismissed can be awarded basic and compensatory awards. However, compensation can be reduced if the employee’s conduct has contributed to their dismissal. This is referred to as ‘contributory conduct’ or ‘contributory fault’.
The background
Mr. I submitted a grievance in May 2023 to his employer. Later, on 6 June, he posted his written grievance on Facebook and added some comments at the end of the post, in which he said that ‘capitalism was a dictatorship of capitalists’ which was ‘evil and has to be destroyed’. He posted on Facebook again on 9 June and 15 July. Mr. I was dismissed on 31 July for his comments in his post on 6 June. Mr. I appealed against his dismissal. By the date of the appeal, he had posted again on Facebook with details of his appeal. The appeal manager took into account all of the posts and rejected his appeal.
The claim
Mr. I issued claims in the Employment Tribunal, including unfair dismissal. The Tribunal found that the reason for dismissal was conduct, due mainly to the post on Facebook on 6 June. However, it found that the dismissal was unfair. Factors taken into account included that Mr. I had not been sent the email and internet usage policy and had not been trained on social media guidelines; he had not been asked to remove the Facebook post of 6 June; he had not been suspended; his mitigation had not been properly considered; a lesser sanction had not been considered and there was no evidence that the post had attracted the attention of the wider public. The Tribunal found that Mr. I had contributed to his dismissal and reduced his compensation by 10%. It also ordered reinstatement.
Contributory fault
The employer appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal against the Tribunal’s decision about compensation. The EAT upheld the appeal. The EAT clarified the legal principles when considering a reduction in compensation for contributory fault.
When considering a reduction to the basic award, the individual’s conduct must have occurred before the dismissal. The employer does not need to have known about it at the time of dismissal. Conduct after dismissal cannot be taken into account. In this case, the Tribunal should have analysed whether Mr. I was guilty of any blameworthy conduct in his posts on 6 June, 9 June and / or 15 July, all of which were before his dismissal.
The compensatory award can be reduced where the dismissal was caused or contributed to by any action of the employee. The employer must have known about the employee’s conduct at the time of the dismissal, and it must have been taken into account in the decision to dismiss. Any conduct taken into account at the appeal stage must have caused or contributed to the decision to uphold the dismissal. In this case, the Tribunal should have analysed the extent to which the 6 June, 9 June, 15 July and any of the later posts caused or contributed to the dismissal by being taken into account at the disciplinary or appeal hearing.
The EAT sent the matter back to the Tribunal to consider. The EAT also found that the Tribunal failed to consider whether Mr. I’s conduct during the Tribunal process, for example likening the actions of the employer’s staff to that of Nazis, meant that reinstatement was practicable.
Comment
The reduction in compensation can be anything up to and including 100%. A reduction is often requested by employers where an employee has been dismissed for misconduct. Whether an individual’s conduct should result in a reduction to the compensatory award is a question for the Tribunal depending on the facts of the case.
We can provide bespoke training on handling disciplinary and grievance issues. Contact us to find out more
28 May 2026
2026 Scrase Law Ltd. This update is for general information only and is not advice. You are recommended to seek professional advice before taking any action on the basis of this update
Related Posts
30th October 2026
What are aggravated damages and when can they be awarded?
The EAT gives guidance on the circumstances in which aggravated damages might…
22nd October 2026
The role of HR in dismissal decision making
To what extent can HR managers be involved in a dismissal decision in a…
16th October 2026
New process for managing flexible working requests – draft Code published
Changes to the way in which employers handle flexible working requests are…




