In the Employment Tribunal, strict time limits apply for submitting and responding to a claim.  Where a claim is received by the Employment Tribunal, it will send notification of the claim to the employer.  The employer has 28 days in which to submit their response to the claim.  In some circumstances, the employer can apply for an extension of time to submit the response.  The employer must explain why the extension is sought.

The background

Mr N was dismissed because he had failed his probationary period.  He issued claims including of discrimination in the Employment Tribunal on 27 December 2022.  The employer submitted a response 10 months out of time, on 22 December 2023, with an application to extend time.

The application to extend the time limit

The issue was whether the employer should be granted an extension of time to submit their response.  The employer argued that it was unaware of the claim until 19 December 2023 when a record of preliminary hearing was sent to its head office.  However, the Tribunal found that four items of correspondence from the Tribunal had been received by the employer, and they had been ignored.  It also found that six emails had been sent to the employer’s General Manager from Mr N’s solicitors and the Tribunal, which she had deliberately deleted and ignored.  The Tribunal rejected the General Manager’s evidence that she had not seen the emails and found that the explanation for the delay was untrue.  The Tribunal refused the application to extend time to submit the response.

Should the time limit be extended?

The employer appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT).  The EAT upheld the Tribunal’s decision.  The Tribunal had considered the relevant facts, including the length of delay, the false explanation, the prejudice to both parties and the merits of the defence.

The EAT gave guidance on the three discretionary factors to be considered, derived from case law:

  • The explanation for the delay. The longer the delay, the more important it is for the employer to provide a satisfactory explanation which is full and honest.
  • The balance of prejudice. The Tribunal is entitled to assess the prejudice to each party and take it into account.
  • The merits of the defence. The Tribunal is entitled to consider the apparent strength or weakness of the defence, but the fact that a defence has merit does not mean that an extension must be granted.

However, it noted that the Tribunal should consider all relevant factors.

Comment

The time limits involved in the Tribunal process, both for submitting claims and for submitting responses are strict.  A Tribunal can extend time for an employer to submit their response, and has wide discretion.  The EAT noted in this case that the employer does not commence the claim, and should not be prevented from advancing an arguable defence because of honestly admitted and explained procedural default, unless the default has caused significant prejudice to the other party or demonstrates wilful disobedience to tribunal rules.

However, it is vitally important for employers to deal with any claim or correspondence received from the Tribunal without delay and employers should ensure that there are robust processes in place.  The general position is that a response that is received after the 28-day time-limit will be rejected.  The employer can apply for an extension of time, but there is no guarantee that the application will be granted.

Costco Wholesale UK Ltd v Nash

19 June 2026

2026 Scrase Law Ltd. This update is for general information only and is not advice. You are recommended to seek professional advice before taking any action on the basis of this update

Related Posts

Privacy Preference Center