A person has a disability under the Equality Act 2010 (the Act) if they have a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on their ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. An adverse effect is ‘substantial’ if it is more than minor or trivial. The effect of an impairment is ‘long term’ if it has lasted or is likely to last for at least 12 months. ‘Normal day-to-day activities’ includes normal workplace activities.
The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has issued an Employment Statutory Code of Practice which Tribunals must take into account in any case in which it appears to be relevant. The Code includes the principle that there is no need for a person to establish a medically diagnosed cause for their impairment. What is important to consider is the effect of the impairment, not the cause.
The background
Mr S has diagnoses of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and ADHD. He issued claims of disability discrimination in the Employment Tribunal after he applied unsuccessfully for a job with HLL. At a Preliminary Hearing, the question for the Tribunal to consider was whether Mr S had a disability within the meaning of the Act.
The claim
The Tribunal found that Mr S was not disabled within the meaning of the Act. It found that he clearly had a mental impairment on the basis of the autism and ADHD diagnoses. However, it went on to find that the impairment did not have a substantial adverse effect on his ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.
Is there a disability?
Mr S appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT). He argued that the decision that he did not have a disability was perverse in light of the confirmed diagnosis of Autism and ADHD.
The EAT noted that when considering whether an employee has a disability under the Act:
- In judging whether the adverse effect is substantial, the comparison is between the individual as they are and as they hypothetically would be without the impairment.
- It is sufficient if the claimant’s impairment has a substantial adverse effect on just one day-to-day activity.
- The Tribunal must not weigh what an individual cannot do against what they can do.
The EAT found that in this case, the Tribunal had not applied those principles.
It noted that where a Tribunal has evidence of a clinical diagnosis of autism or ADHD, unless there is some reason to doubt the reliability of that clinical judgment, the Tribunal must take that diagnosis into account as evidence that the individual has that impairment.
The EAT also noted that a diagnosis reflects a clinician’s opinion as to the extent to which the individual’s functioning differs to the ‘norm’. The diagnosis is therefore relevant to the question of whether the impairment has a ‘substantial adverse effect’.
The EAT allowed the appeal and sent it back to a fresh Tribunal to decide whether Mr S is disabled within the meaning of the Act.
Comment
As noted in the judgment, a diagnosis of autism does not in itself always mean that the test for disability is met. The diagnosis can be taken into account as evidence that the individual has the impairment, and as evidence as to the impact of that impairment. However, the Tribunal still needs to make findings about the individual’s ability to carry out day-to-day activities.
Mr H Stedman v Haven Leisure Ltd
We can provide bespoke Equality Awareness training for your business. Contact us to find out more.
31 July 2025
2025 Scrase Law Ltd. This update is for general information only and is not advice. You are recommended to seek professional advice before taking any action on the basis of this update.
Related Posts
30th October 2026
What are aggravated damages and when can they be awarded?
The EAT gives guidance on the circumstances in which aggravated damages might…
22nd October 2026
The role of HR in dismissal decision making
To what extent can HR managers be involved in a dismissal decision in a…
16th October 2026
New process for managing flexible working requests – draft Code published
Changes to the way in which employers handle flexible working requests are…




