How much holiday can an employee carry over to the next holiday year?
When an employee is unable or unwilling to take their statutory annual leave during the holiday year due to sickness absence, they must be allowed to take it following their return to work. This principle applies even if it means allowing the employee to carry holiday over to the next leave year. However, how much holiday is an employee entitled to carry over?
Under the European Working Time Directive (the Directive), every Member State must ensure that a worker is entitled to paid annual holiday of at least four weeks. The Directive is implemented in Great Britain by the Working Time Regulations (the Regulations). Under the Regulations, an employee is entitled to 5.6 weeks’ annual leave. This is made up of the right under the Directive to a minimum of four weeks’ leave each year and an additional 1.6 weeks’ leave.
Under the Regulations, the first four weeks of leave may only be taken in the leave year in respect of which it is due. The Regulations expressly provide that the additional 1.6 weeks’ leave cannot be carried forward unless there is a relevant agreement between the employer and the employee.
In the course of two separate cases under Finnish Law, the Finnish Labour Court asked the European Court of Justice (ECJ) whether Member States can allow more than the four-week entitlement under the Directive but prevent carry over of that additional leave in the event of illness absence.
The ECJ noted that the Directive does not prevent Member States from providing additional holiday to the minimum four-week entitlement under the Directive. Where the Member States provide such additional holiday, this is governed by national law. It is therefore open to Member States to determine the rights or conditions of carry-over of additional holiday in the event of illness.
The fact that Member States limit carry over of holiday to four weeks does not affect the minimum protection guaranteed to workers under the Directive. The ECJ found that the Working Time Directive “must be interpreted as not precluding national rules or collective agreements which provide for the granting of days of paid annual leave which exceed the minimum period of 4 weeks,.. and yet exclude the carrying over of those days of leave on the grounds of illness”.
An earlier decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal had come to the same conclusion that an employer only has to allow an employee to carry forward 4 weeks leave, not 5.6 weeks. However, that decision was contrary to earlier case law which suggested that employers had to allow the employee to carry forward 5.6 weeks’ leave. This ECJ decision is therefore useful clarification for employers.
To comply with the Regulations, employers must allow carry-over of four weeks’ annual leave where a worker on sick leave does not take that holiday in the year in which it accrues. This right is not unlimited, however, and employers can impose a time limit on when the leave that has been carried forward must be taken. Case law has suggested that a sensible limit to the period of carry-over is 18 months from the end of the year in which the leave accrued.
It is sometimes the case, however, that employees have the right under the contract of employment or other contractual agreement to carry forward not just the four weeks’ leave, but also the additional 1.6 weeks leave. Employers should ensure that they continue to comply with their own contracts and policies in relation to carry-over of leave in excess of 4 weeks.
TSN v Hyvinvointialan and AKT v Satamaoperaattorit
29 November 2019
We can offer bespoke employment law training for line managers in your workplace. Contact us for further details.
If you would like to receive monthly employment law updates and news of our events, sign up for our email alerts.
©2020 SCRASE LAW LTD. THIS POST IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATION ONLY AND IS NOT ADVICE. YOU ARE RECOMMENDED TO SEEK COMPETENT PROFESSIONAL ADVICE BEFORE TAKING ANY ACTION ON THE BASIS OF THIS POST