A constructive dismissal claim can arise where an employee with more than two years’ service resigns and alleges that the resignation is because of their employer’s treatment of them. To succeed, the employee would need to show that their resignation was as a result of a fundamental breach of contract by their employer. This could include a breach of the implied term of trust and confidence. The employee would also need to show that they did not delay too long before resigning.
Background
Ms W was employed as Head of Installations by her employer. She was diagnosed with cancer and began a period of sick leave after completing a handover of her work. In her absence, a colleague indicated that she intended to resign. In an effort to retain her, the employer offered the colleague a permanent role of Head of Installations. This was on the assumption that there would be enough work for two Heads of Installation once Ms W returned to work.
Ms W found out about the appointment of her colleague when she saw a post on LinkedIn. Ms W contacted her employer and was assured, inaccurately, that her role would be unaffected. She was not informed that the new role was permanent.
Following discussions about her return to work, the employer gave Ms W a new job description. Ms W believed that she had been demoted. She raised a formal grievance and subsequently resigned, stating that he was unhappy with the way she had been treated, including finding out while she was on sick leave that a colleague had been given her job. She described the employer’s delay in handling the grievance process as the ‘final straw’.
The claim
Ms W issued claims of discrimination and constructive dismissal in the Employment Tribunal. The Tribunal found that appointing a colleague as a permanent Head of Installations without any input from Ms W, and misleading her that the appointment was temporary, was discrimination arising from her disability. However, it found that she had not been constructively dismissed because Ms W’s perception that she had been demoted, which was inaccurate, was the reason for her resignation.
Constructive dismissal?
Ms W appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT). The EAT found that the Tribunal had failed to analyse whether the discriminatory acts amounted to repudiatory breaches of trust and confidence, and whether Ms W was influenced in resigning, even if only in part, because of such breaches. If she was, then her constructive dismissal claim should have succeeded. The Tribunal should then have considered whether her constructive dismissal also amounted to an act of discrimination.
The EAT sent the claim back to the Tribunal to consider the claim of constructive dismissal.
Comment
Cancer is a deemed disability under the Equality Act 2010. If an employee is found to have been discriminated against because of their disability, they can be awarded unlimited damages which would include their wage losses and an injury to feelings award. The EAT noted that not every act of discrimination might be a breach of trust and confidence, but in this case the Tribunal had not explained why the discriminatory acts did not amount to repudiatory breaches and did not form part of Ms W’s reasons for resigning.
This judgment was reached in 2023 but was not published by the EAT until 2025. In the meantime, the claim went back to the Tribunal where Ms W succeeded in her claims that she was constructively dismissed and that her dismissal was discriminatory. Ms W was awarded a total of over £1.2 million, including an award of £40,000 for injury to feelings.
We can provide bespoke Equality Awareness training for your business. Contact us to find out more.
30 September 2025.
2025 Scrase Law Ltd. This update is for general information only and is not advice. You are recommended to seek professional advice before taking any action on the basis of this update.
Related Posts
30th October 2026
What are aggravated damages and when can they be awarded?
The EAT gives guidance on the circumstances in which aggravated damages might…
22nd October 2026
The role of HR in dismissal decision making
To what extent can HR managers be involved in a dismissal decision in a…
16th October 2026
New process for managing flexible working requests – draft Code published
Changes to the way in which employers handle flexible working requests are…




